Changing my mind - Livre d'Or








Miscellaneous. Eclectic. Random. Perhaps markedly literate, or at least suffering from the compulsion to read any text that presents itself, including cereal boxes. * Blogroll * Strange words * More links * Bookies * Microblog * Recent comments * Humans only * Second degree * By topic * Cool posts * Writing * New post

Tags

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *



livredor
Changing my mind
Wednesday, 28 September 2016 at 06:04 pm
Tags:

Previous Entry Next Entry


I aspire to be the kind of person who thinks for myself and most importantly changes my views when I learn new information. And that means I spend some amount of time worrying about whether I'm actually living up to that. There are lots of pressures pushing people, including me, towards opinions that are not based on evidence and convincing reasoning. The biggest one is probably conformity, I do have a strong drive to hold opinions that match the accepted ideas in my social circle. And that's a bit self-reinforcing, because I'm likely to be friends with people I broadly agree with and then when I hear arguments from people I already like I'm more likely to be swayed by them. Plus there's all the usual biases, I'm more skeptical of evidence for ideas I disagree with and relatively receptive to arguments that support views I already hold. And like many people I find changing my mind a bit scary because it implies repudiating the person I once was who held the now discarded view.

Part of the reason this came to mind lately was that some people were passing round a link to Scott Alexander's persuasion experiment. I find Scott Alexander very annoying for a lot of reasons, particularly his whining about how a feminist was mean to him one time and therefore feminism and all of social justice are an evil cult. But he does sometimes have some useful things to say and one thing I do admire about him is that he's quite committed to being precisely the sort of person who does update his ideas based on rationally examined evidence. And that's not my major goal in life but it is something I care about.

So anyway, I tried reading a lightly randomized essay aimed at convincing me to be scared of what the Rationality crowd call AI threat. And I was not at all persuaded, because although I did my best to be open-minded about the idea that I should be scared of the development of an all powerful, self-improving AI bent on the destruction of humanity, I find the concept so obviously ludicrous that no amount of writing in a pseudo-academic style with footnoted citations was going to shift my position. Plus I'm prejudiced against Alexander (as far as I know he didn't write the essay, but he promoted it) and fear of a powerful, destructive AI monster is a trope that I already associate with my negative feelings towards the Less Wrong / New Atheist / Rationality set. I think it's exactly an example of the kind of errors you make when you over-estimate your own intelligence and try to understand the world just by thinking really hard and without actually engaging with existing scholarship.

This did lead to a bit of self-doubt: am I just losing my ability to change my mind? Should I in fact be worrying about AI threat and I'm just blocking myself from doing so because I don't want to challenge my existing views and biases? (Actually I think the whole debate is directly analogous to Pascal's Wager: the fact that a clever person can invent an outcome that would basically be infinitely bad doesn't mean either that that outcome is likely, or that we should spend maximal amounts of energy trying to avoid that bad outcome.)

Then I did change a previously held belief, because people on my Tumblr dashboard were talking about this meta-analysis of studies about the effects of punishing children by spanking. Unfortunately the study is paywalled and I can't quickly find the Tumblr post where someone had put up a pirate version of the full paper. But basically Gershoff convinced me that there is a clear evidence base against spanking, given that she found lots of studies with small but reproducible negative long-term outcomes and essentially no studies with statistically meaningful benefits. But I don't really feel proud of myself for changing my view here, because for one thing basically all my friends are against any kind of corporal punishment so I'm just removing what was previously an outlier belief and replacing it with the group consensus. And for another it's a completely abstract question since I don't have or plan to have children so it makes no difference how I regard the arguments about childrearing practices. Besides, siderea and [personal profile] rmc28 had already half convinced me when I mentioned the issue before. So it was really quite easy for me to shut up the critical voice in my head pointing out that Gershoff has based her whole academic career around campaigning against corporal punishment and psychology has a replication crisis and a meta-analysis can be cherry-picked... You know what, self, that's as good a meta-analysis as plenty that you'd unquestioningly accept if they didn't require you to change your opinion, so there's no need to be overly picky about this one.

So those are the two extremes. I'm unpersuaded by an article espousing a view I think is not just wrong, but ridiculous, and more so because it's written in a style and associated with a group I disapprove of. I'm persuaded by a peer-reviewed meta-analysis to change a view I was only mildly committed to anyway to one which is more aligned with my social group. What I'd like from my readers, if you'd like to play along, is for you to persuade me of some new ideas. Please send me links to arguments you find persuasive on issues you expect me to disagree with. (I'm also quite interested to discover what you think I might find objectionable; I think I've been pretty open about my opinions here over the years, but of course everybody will have their own impressions and assumptions about me.)

I've turned off screening for anon comments, so if you think your views might be met with social opprobium please feel free to offer arguments without saying who you are.

I prefer comments at Dreamwidth. There are currently comment count unavailable comments there. You can use your LJ address as an OpenID, or just write your name.


Whereaboooots: Keele University, Staffordshire, England
Moooood: curiouscurious
Tuuuuune: Qntal: Noit e dia
Discussion: 9 contributions | Contribute something
Tags:

Previous Entry Next Entry




Contribute something
View all comments chronologically



From:(Anonymous)
Date:July 25th, 2017 10:46 am (UTC)
299 days after journal entry

Hot sale! E-gift card amazon with a face value of $ 2000 for only $ 500.

(Link)
Hot sale! E-gift card amazon with a face value of $ 2000 for only $ 500.
https://amazonegiftcardcheap.wordpress.com
The promotion will last until July 31, 2017. After July 31, the price will be $ 1000
https://amazonegiftcardcheap.wordpress.com
(Reply to this comment) (Thread)
From:(Anonymous)
Date:August 21st, 2017 10:51 pm (UTC)
327 days after journal entry

Mature purlieus

(Link)
Check my new devise
http://chubby.feed.bdsmsex.top/?post.theresa
swinger party porn older en and younger female porn heather veitch porn movie porn theaters in grand rapids free virgin girl porn
(Reply to this comment) (Thread)
From:(Anonymous)
Date:August 24th, 2017 07:28 am (UTC)
329 days after journal entry

Free galleries

(Link)
My updated project is next!
catalogue lingerie sexy film downloading best free strategy gamkes android market android download gratis top games tablet android
http://erotic.googleplay.twiclub.in/?page.katie
buy cell phones android software download newgames com games wallpaper wallpapers wallpaper downloading
(Reply to this comment) (Thread)
From:(Anonymous)
Date:August 24th, 2017 08:28 am (UTC)
329 days after journal entry

Loose galleries

(Link)
Started unusual web throw
http://teen.polish.yopoint.in/?entry-nathalie
bulgarian porn gergana sexy squirt porn plumper porn thumbs porn dragonball z cartoons down blouse porn pictures
(Reply to this comment) (Thread)
From:(Anonymous)
Date:September 8th, 2017 03:09 am (UTC)
344 days after journal entry

Почти ЛЮБЫЕ Проблемы со здоровьем решает Ламинин. Он н

(Link)
Мы говорим - Нет ЛЕКАРСТВАМ! Laminine LPGN разрабатывался почти 100 лет. Кто владеет информацией - ЗДОРОВ! Это МЛМ из США. Мы Восстановили Здоровье и Достойно Зарабатываем. Можно быть скептиком и остаться с болячками. Можно поговорить, узнать, почитать и ЗАДУМАТЬСЯ. Смотрите видео - 3 минуты ЧУДА.
Исповедь приговоренного медициной. https://youtu.be/dnxmoWu8tEY
(Reply to this comment) (Thread)
From:(Anonymous)
Date:September 9th, 2017 10:02 pm (UTC)
346 days after journal entry

v77bfcqx

(Link)
Показать все товары и услуги фирмы Фирма 12050 "DaVanti, мебельный центр"Teлефоны: 0674339927, 0674339937, 0674339920Факс: 0445370797 E-mail: info davanti. Двухядерный нетбук Lenovo S10-3. [url=http://manyhamster.tk:65509/dsad.php ]Толпой русской порно онлайн [/url]В 2012 году их должно остаться не более 15, но четких, понятных и самое главное с конкретными целями и задачами. Издание вправе отказать в размещении Материалов без объяснения причин отказа, а также удалить Материалы по своему усмотрению, если их содержание противоречит нормам этики и морали, не соответствует требованиям, установленным законодательством Российской Федерации, и противоречит требованиям настоящих Правил. [url=http://vsexus.tk:65446/dsad.php ]Массаж мастурбация [/url]Металлические анкеры Анкерные винты Анкеры распорные. Подать объявление Flagma Кременчуг Войти Регистрация Объявления Вакансии Резюме Компании Машины Грузы Расстояния Подать объявление 8 объявлений Перетяжка в Кременчуге Изготовление и перетяжка сидушек для лодок,гидроциклов. Прошу поделиться методами поиска воды. [url=http://manyaebus.ml:65436 ]Женщина отказываться секса [/url]Киев Бурение скважин под воду Бурение скважин в труднодоступных местах,Харькова и Области. [url=http://myjustpx.ml:65497/dsad.php ]Порно видео сын просит [/url]Сумы Ремонт пылесосов в г. Декор из пенопласта, фасадный пенопластовый фриз, пенопластовый фриз с полимерным покрытием, пенополистерольная крошка. Москитные сетки, подоконники, отливы и козырьки, защитные роллеты, горизонтальные и вертикальные жалюзи. Показать все товары и услуги фирмы Фирма 26420 "Сивт ООО"Teлефоны: 050 3530440, 050 3848811, 8 04497 51090Факс: 04597 51090 E-mail: info si-vt. [url=http://31.131.27.194:6069/ ]Порно мужика 1 баба [/url]Одесса "Teлефоны: 0487004121, 0487069471, 0949321472Факс: 0487069472 E-mail: diamantsklo gmail. Мы обязательно просматриваем все обращения, но из-за их большого количества не всегда отвечаем на них напрямую. Стоит отметить, что магазин действительно приятно удивил горожан не только оформлением и уровнем сервиса, но и общей концепцией, соответствующей глобальным стандартам обслуживания Vodafone во всех странах Европы. На 10 доз 8 грн Ошейник Бурди от блох и клещей - 2в1 для котов 35см. [url=http://163.172.181.251:3016/ ]Нарезка женской мастурбации [/url]Сумы Ремонт посудомоечных машин в г. Они не требуют инсталляции на компьютер и работают с любого диска или вашей флешки: Mozilla Firefox или Google Chrome200 грн. Вам нужна кухня уже завтра? Universal - данный проходной элемент применяется для монтажа труб и вентиляторов диаметром 110-160 мм, антенных выходом и уплотнителей на кровле, покрытой керамической и цементно-песчаной черепицей. [url=http://uzbpmany.cf:65481/ ]Скрытую камеру реально мамой [/url]
#425gnfhvyg4522_#$%&^#
(Reply to this comment) (Thread)
From:(Anonymous)
Date:September 13th, 2017 01:38 pm (UTC)
349 days after journal entry

Jaka zabawka dla chlopca 8 lat

(Link)
Inside three months, babies could just goal of these, zero sort them other accessible, as well as inside our point it is testing to be able to invent a young child without having them. The talk will target radio-controlled gadget. To begin with, plan in addition to devices with rural power end up being formed pertaining to composition with dangerous or maybe inaccessible areas if you are. Later, have got shifted on the every day level, we were holding transformed in to amazing toys for little one. The a number of manners and types of constructions usually puzzles mum or dad, although children live very well versed inside the qualities of your model.
[url=http://912.wltoys.co.pl]Zabawki wltoys[/url]
(Reply to this comment) (Thread)
From:(Anonymous)
Date:September 15th, 2017 06:15 pm (UTC)
352 days after journal entry
(Link)
порно мать и сын реально русское http://cutt.us/pJG7Y фото как я кончаю на киску
найти порно со звздами зарубежной сцены http://cutt.us/DtMyQ с привязыванием и пытками порно рассказы
смотреть порно онлайн как мастурбируют и кончают целочки http://cutt.us/JrGiQ реальное порно в больнице с медсестрой
секс подарила подругу на день рождения видео http://cutt.us/UxEvy порно фильмы мать и сын новинки
анальный секс в порно видео без регистрации http://cutt.us/Gdmhh смотреть порно скрытая камера подглядывание за девушками
почему во время секса не могу долго кончать http://cutt.us/xQIY смоттреть онлайн порно как целка дрочет
мама увидела какой у сына большой русское порно http://cutt.us/Fg7YO частное фото девушка ласкает себя пальчиком
реальные истории из жизни о сексе с транссексуалами http://cutt.us/zKtRQ порно рассказы муж би приводит любовника для жены
http://cutt.us/DrckQ
http://cutt.us/ZCbB2
http://cutt.us/psgKH
http://cutt.us/VPjMR
http://cutt.us/yenE4
http://cutt.us/cTfjW
http://cutt.us/VThlg
http://cutt.us/0MFzF
http://cutt.us/hncno
http://cutt.us/4I9wD
http://cutt.us/UIbha
http://cutt.us/Nr6ro
(Reply to this comment) (Thread)
From:(Anonymous)
Date:September 24th, 2017 09:10 am (UTC)
360 days after journal entry

Unshackle galleries

(Link)
Started up to date cobweb throw
google download games android 2 3 game how to block porn on google sex girls downloads how to create an app for free
http://pornmarket.replyme.pw/?mail.kiley
system update in android mobogenie apps market apk free games download apps construction real porn apps
(Reply to this comment) (Thread)



Contribute something
View all comments chronologically